1. Home
  2. Home Warranty

Find the Best Home Warranty in Indianapolis, IN

A home warranty covers the cost of repairing plumbing, major appliances and home systems that aren’t covered by homeowners insurance. Having a home warranty is an especially good idea in Indianapolis where hot summers and cold winters add extra wear and tear to your heating and cooling systems. We researched the best home warranty in Indianapolis to help you decide what coverage works best for your home.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Accredited Partner

    Compare Top Home Warranties, Service Plans

    #1 OUR FAVORITE
    American Home Shield
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • 4 coverage plans
    • Starting at $75 deductible
    • Coverage regardless of age or make
    • Available in Indianapolis

    Be sure with The Shield.

    Learn More (888) 395-0951 Read More
    #2
    Choice Home Warranty
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • Experienced contractors
    • Submit claims online
    • First month free
    • Available in Indianapolis

    Choice Home Warranty offers comprehensive protection plans that protect against the high cost of repair or replacement of properly maintained major systems and appliances.

    Learn More (732) 765-6416 Read More
    #3
    2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • Comprehensive coverage for systems and appliances
    • Covers HVAC, plumbing, refrigerator, dishwasher, oven and more
    • 6,000+ authorized, independent service contractors
    • 35+ years experience

    2-10 Home Buyers Warranty has plans to cover appliances and systems for all homes and structural coverage for new homes. They've protected over 5.5 million homes and are well established

    Learn More (800) 743-4210 Read More
    #4
    Total Home Protection
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • Plans as low as $1/day
    • Prescreened & local technicians
    • 24/7 customer service
    • Available in Indianapolis

    Offers 2 coverage plans that both cover select systems and appliances. Premium costs vary by location and home with standard deductibles of $60.

    Learn More (704) 253-8240 Read More
    #5
    America's 1st Choice Home Club
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • 2 coverage plan options
    • Fixed rate locked in with no year-to-year increases
    • No limit on service requests
    • Flexibility to choose your own service technician

    With four plans to choose from based on your needs, and the ability to pay by the month, or to get a discount pay yearly, America's First Choice is a great pick for any homeowner.

    Learn More (678) 236-0645 Read More
    #6
    Select Home Warranty
    Overall satisfaction rating
    • 2018 Best in Service award winner
    • Lowest deductable
    • $60 service fee
    • Available in Indianapolis

    Select Home Warranty provides home warranty service plans that cover home repairs. They have a wide range of options to choose from and offer customizable plans.

    Learn More (317) 754-6642 Read More

    Why do I need a home warranty in Indianapolis?

    Indianapolis Skyline

    When major appliances break or critical home systems fail, it’s necessary to replace them as quickly as possible. Most people don’t want to live without a refrigerator or heat during a cold Indianapolis winter. These repairs, however, are often expensive, which can leave you in a stressful situation where a significant expense must be paid immediately. Home warranties protect you in these situations.

    Before purchasing a home warranty in Indianapolis, it’s important to know what it is. A home warranty is not homeowners insurance, but it works as a supplement to homeowners insurance and covers repairs to essential home items, such as heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) systems and large appliances. On the other hand, your warranty will not cover a crack in your foundation or a leaking roof.

    How to avoid a home warranty scam in Indianapolis

    When you’re shopping for a home warranty in Indianapolis, make sure to ask providers if they’re licensed with the Indiana Department of Insurance. Be sure to read the fine print in the home warranty as well – you’ll want to understand what is and isn’t covered to make sure you’re buying the service you need. The contract may also require you to perform regular maintenance for the warranty to be valid.

    Be sure to insist the company performs a home inspection of your appliances and your heating, cooling and plumbing systems. Many home warranty companies will advertise this isn’t necessary, but the lack of an inspection can open a loophole for unethical companies to avoid paying claims. Without the inspection, there’s no documentation proving the appliance or system wasn’t broken before the warranty was purchased.

    Home warranty cost and coverage in Indianapolis

    In Indianapolis, the average cost of a warranty is $132 per year, which is well below the national average of $475 for a basic plan. Typically, a warranty on your property will cover the following:

    • Plumbing systems
    • Range/oven
    • Dishwasher
    • Sump pump
    • Water heater
    • Heating, cooling and electrical system components
    • Built-in microwave

    Different levels of plans are available in Indianapolis. Some plans may only cover a few critical items, but others offer expanded coverage that may include items like hot tubs, televisions and other appliances. Read the warranty carefully to see what’s covered and ask questions to be sure the warranty suits your needs before making any purchases.

    Home Warranty Reviews

    American Home Shield

    American Home Shield has more than 50 years of experience and has paid out more than $2 billion in claims over the past five years. The company has three level of plans and allows you to build a custom plan. Many reviews praise the company’s personable and courteous technicians, but some customers in Indianapolis say they’ve had issues with poor customer service.

    American Home Shield Learn More (888) 395-0951

    Choice Home Warranty

    Choice Home Warranty offers comprehensive plans that protect against costly repairs or replacement of properly maintained heating and cooling systems and appliances. One Indianapolis reviewer wrote the company has “excellent and extremely prompt service” and that he “will continue to recommend Choice Home Warranty to [his] family and friends.”

    Choice Home Warranty Learn More (732) 765-6416

    2-10 Home Buyers Warranty

    With more than 35 years in business, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is an industry leader that covers appliances like a dishwasher, refrigerator, washing machine and air conditioner, to name a few. Whether you’re buying, selling or building a home, 2-10 offers a service agreement to protect you from unexpected repair costs.

    2-10 Home Buyers Warranty Learn More (800) 743-4210

    Total Home Protection

    With plans starting at just $1 per day, THP is popular among Indiana residents on a budget. Total Home Protection has two plans that offer add-ons for enhanced coverage. File claims online or over the phone. Pre-approved contractors are sent to your home for only the deductible charged.

    Total Home Protection Learn More (704) 253-8240

    America's 1st Choice Home Club

    With tiered pricing options, AFC Home Club makes it easy to see what is and is not covered under its three plans. Choose one that fits your home’s needs and buy extra coverage to protect additional appliances and systems. There’s no deductible, only a $60 service fee. Plans include restaurant gift cards and a retail savings program for cash back at 5,000 retailers.

    America's 1st Choice Home Club Learn More (678) 236-0645

    Select Home Warranty

    Select Home Warranty advertises an extensive national network of licensed, pre-approved and certified contractors. The company’s service plans cover rental properties, mobile homes, manufactured homes, single-family homes, multiple units and condos. Many customers in Indianapolis recommend the company for its hassle-free claims processing.

    Select Home Warranty Learn More (317) 754-6642