1. Home
  2. Extended Auto Warranty

Find the Best Extended Auto Warranty Companies in Indianapolis, IN

In a city like Indianapolis where roads in poor condition can cause mechanical damage to your vehicle, an extended auto warranty provides security by helping defray the cost of expensive, unexpected repairs. We researched the best extended auto warranty in Indianapolis to protect your vehicle.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Authorized Partner

Compare Top Extended Auto Warranties

Endurance
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Direct provider, not a broker of warranties
  • Pays mechanic directly
  • Covers vehicles up to 10 yrs or 150,000 miles
  • Available in Indianapolis

Coverage when you need it!

Learn More Read More
CARCHEX
Overall satisfaction rating
  • No-haggle guarantee
  • Roadside plans for $59.95
  • Available in Indianapolis
  • Mobile app

Plans available for cars with up to 250,000 miles. Multiple plan options from different providers. Terms up to 10 years. Finance over six, 12, 18 or 24 months. Comes with a 30-day return policy.

Learn More (866) 254-0172 Read More
CarShield
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Indianapolis
  • Powertrain & specialty plans
  • Coverage for recreational vehicles
  • Plans for every vehicle & budget

Markets warranty plans for cars and motorcycles backed by American Auto Shield. Coverage, deductibles and payments vary by vehicle age and mileage. Contracts are transferable and come with a 30-day return policy.

Learn More (800) 974-9385 Read More
Infinite Auto
Overall satisfaction rating
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Guarantees 100% payment in event of any breakdown
  • Available in Indianapolis

Offers three coverage options for used cars. Guarantees 100% payment of all covered repairs, less the deductible. Waiting period is 30 days and 1,000 miles.

Read More
Protect My Car
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 3 plans available
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Indianapolis
  • Rental car benefits

Offers plans for newer and older vehicles up to 20 years old and 299,999 miles. All services provided in-house by Protect My Car employees. Special offers for military personnel. Not available in California.

Learn More (609) 401-2762
AA Auto Protection
  • Wear & tear coverage options
  • Resolves claims quickly
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Indianapolis
Location
Serves residents in
Indianapolis, IN
(888) 222-4445
Delta Auto Protect
Overall satisfaction rating
  • ASE-licensed technicians on staff
  • Available in Indianapolis
  • Customizable plans
  • Price match promise

Offers three levels of protection. Covers vehicles up to 20 years old with up to 140,000 miles. Coverage is not available in Alabama, California, Florida, Missouri, Texas and Washington.

Location
Serves residents in
Indianapolis, IN
(866) 598-5429
American Auto Shield
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Indianapolis
  • Serving customers for over a decade
  • Resolves claims quickly
  • Your choice of mechanic

Does not sell vehicle service contracts directly. Partners with third-party providers to offer eight programs for cars up to 250,000 miles, plus coverage for motorcycles, ATVs and dirt bikes. Available nationwide.

Location
Serves residents in
Indianapolis, IN
(800) 531-1925

How to choose an extended auto warranty in Indianapolis

Indianapolis Skyline

Indianapolis roads can take a toll on your car. More than 37,000 residents complained about potholes in the city in the first nine months of 2018 – more than double the number for all of 2017. Poor road conditions can lead to long-term damage to your car, and one motorist told reporters that potholes on the city’s south side were so bad her mechanic told her that they dislodged her engine, causing her SUV to stall.

Making matters worse, the city’s investments in transit infrastructure have historically been modest. Indianapolis spends less per capita on mass transit than practically any other metropolitan area in the U.S. with a population greater than one million residents. Indianapolis has no commuter rail service, and only four percent of its residents live within a quarter-mile of a bus stop with service at least every 15 minutes. As a result, less than one percent of the metro area’s population uses public transit on a daily basis.

An extended auto warranty keeps you from being stranded without transportation by covering the cost of unexpected repairs. Unlike car insurance, which covers damage from accidents, an extended auto warranty provides coverage when your car has mechanical problems.

Different extended auto warranty plans are available in Indianapolis, but they typically don't cover routine maintenance for brake pads, tires, air cleaners or oil changes. Some plans include extra features, such as towing, roadside assistance or reimbursement of up to 150 percent for a trip that is interrupted because of car problems.

Some plans require a deductible – generally between $50 and $100 – while others pay for repair costs in total.

Here are a few questions to consider when deciding whether to purchase an extended auto warranty:

  • Who is providing the warranty? An extended warranty is often available through either the original equipment manufacturer or a third-party company. The OEM warranty generally extends the original warranty that comes with a new car, but a third-party warranty can be customized to cover a variety of problems.
  • What’s the best price? Do your research before buying your car; you might get the best deal at the time of purchase rather than shopping for the extended auto warranty after the original manufacturer warranty expires.
  • What does your extended warranty cover? A basic extended auto warranty in Indianapolis may not cover many of the car parts that suffer the most wear-and-tear. Many extended auto warranty companies sell plans in tiers with different pricing and levels of coverage, so make sure you’re getting the coverage you need and expect. Plans range from bumper-to-bumper warranties to ones that only cover core components, such as the engine and transmission.

Extended Auto Warranty Reviews

Endurance

Endurance is one of the nation’s largest providers of extended auto warranties and offers a full 30-day, money-back guarantee. Indianapolis customers say they appreciate the easy payment process and excellent customer service.

Endurance Learn More

CARCHEX

CARCHEX offers free online quotes and service plans that include towing, roadside assistance and rental cars. The company consistently receives high marks from Indianapolis reviewers for its customer service and responsiveness in handling repairs.

CARCHEX Learn More (866) 254-0172

CarShield

CarShield offers a wide range of service plans that come with 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement, towing and flexible payment plans. Customers give the company high marks for customer service and hassle-free claims processing, but some people have complained of high-pressure sales tactics and reimbursement shortfalls.

CarShield Learn More (800) 974-9385

Infinite Auto

Infinite Auto Protection offers three extended auto warranty plans. Each comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance. Customers like being able to take their vehicles to any dealership or certified repair shop and say Infinite Auto Protection has an efficient claims process and low deductible.

Infinite Auto